Munich restaurateur Alexander Egger filed a constitutional complaint on 13 November 2026 against the decision on the allocation of large Oktoberfest tents. His company, WE Gutshof GmbH, turned to the Federal Constitutional Court, as the Süddeutsche Zeitung reported on 20 November. Egger wants the pitches for the tents to be put out to tender across Europe. His lawyers argue that the Bavarian Higher Regional Court should have referred the case to the European Court of Justice before reaching its decision.
The Bavarian court rejected a complaint against the allocation of two pitches on 16 October 2026. It reasoned that the admission contracts were not service concessions, to which European and procurement law procurement law would apply. The City of Munich organises the Oktoberfest, but had not itself taken on the task of operating the festival tents. The application for a procurement review was therefore inadmissible from the outset, in the court’s view.
The dispute centres on the legal significance of the contracts between the city and the operators. Under a service concession, a public authority engages a company to provide a service whose operation the company itself is financially responsible for. Egger and his lawyers consider a Europe-wide tender necessary. The court, by contrast, saw no sufficient link between the operation of the individual tents and the city’s task of organising the festival.
The question of an obligation to operate the tents also played a part. The court found that the admission contracts for 2026 contained no such obligation. According to the Süddeutsche Zeitung, a corresponding provision had been removed from the city’s operating regulations. Egger’s lawyers reportedly suspect that the change was intended to prevent a Europe-wide tender. The court saw no basis for this argument, the report said, because the city had no direct financial interest in the operation of the festival tents.
The lawyers also challenge the decision not to refer the case to the European Court of Justice. They consider this a breach of the right to have a case heard by the judge designated by law. The Bavarian Higher Regional Court had found that a referral was unnecessary: its interpretation was consistent with the European court’s case law.
A further legal remedy was unsuccessful. According to the report, on 18 November 2026 the Bavarian court declared an application for a hearing review inadmissible. It was intended to have any potentially overlooked arguments examined.
The constitutional complaint does not mean that a new tender has already been ordered. Even if it succeeds in Karlsruhe the case would, according to the Süddeutsche Zeitung, be sent back to the Bavarian court for a fresh examination. In its decision, the court had expressly left open whether the city had allocated the two pitches correctly on substantive grounds: this question was generally subject to review by the administrative courts and had not formed part of the procurement proceedings.
Editor: Mira Cadena (Article created with AI assistance).