On this day in history

What happened in Germany on 17 November?

On 17 November, Bismarck announces social security in 1881, Papen’s government resigns in 1932, German occupiers close Czech universities in 1939, and Hans Modrow advocates a treaty community in 1989.

Social security, parliamentary impotence, the terror of occupation and the search for a new German order: four events on 17 November take us through very different chapters of German history. In 1881, the Reich leadership announces a social policy programme. In 1932, a government that hopes to manage without solid parliamentary support fails. In 1939, German occupiers direct their violence against Czech students and universities. In 1989, [Hans Modrow] tries Hans Modrow, through reforms and closer cooperation with the Federal Republic, to preserve his state’s independence. What these events have in common is not an inevitable course of development, but the question of how state power is justified, exercised and constrained.

Germany on 17 November

17 November 1881: Bismarck announces a social security programme

On 17 November 1881, Chancellor Otto von Bismarck reads out at the opening of the Reichstag in the proclaimed a “free socialist republic” from the Berlin Palace a message from the ailing Emperor Wilhelm I. The Imperial message declares social security for workers to be a task of Reich policy. It promises a revised bill on accident insurance, a reorganisation of the sickness insurance system for trades and industry, and better protection in the event of loss of earning capacity through old age or disability. This gives an ambitious social policy initiative the explicit backing of the highest authority in the monarchy. The statement links material assistance with a political goal: domestic peace. In effect, it says that repression alone is not enough to counter social democracy; workers’ welfare must also be promoted. The Anti-Socialist Law in force since 1878 and the announced social reforms are therefore not two separate political strands. Rather, repression and social integration are intended to complement one another. This combination explains the programme’s top-down character: the Reich leadership wants to alleviate social hardship while also stabilising the existing order. 17 November marks the announcement of the programme, not the introduction of a finished insurance system. The message itself refers to further deliberations, the need for funding and organisational difficulties. It also does not rely solely on direct state administration, but on collective forms of organisation under state protection. Its historical significance therefore lies above all in the public promise of responsibility: illness, accidents and loss of earning capacity due to old age are no longer to be treated solely as private misfortunes. The form this responsibility will take remains a matter for legislation.

17 November 1932: Franz von Papen submits his government’s resignation

On 17 November 1932, Chancellor Franz von Papen asks President Paul von Hindenburg to dismiss his cabinet. Hindenburg accepts the resignation offer the same day. This follows failed talks with parties in the Reichstag: Papen is unable to secure sufficient political support for his government. Despite the resignation, the cabinet initially remains in office on a caretaker basis. The resignation and the actual change at the head of government therefore do not take place on the same day. The failure highlights a fundamental problem with presidential government. Papen bases his authority on the Reich President, but has no solid parliamentary foundation. Nor is there any sign of a majority for his course after the November Reichstag election. A new conflict with parliament is foreseeable: the went to a window in the Reichstag Reichstag can pass a motion of no confidence in the government or repeal its emergency decrees. Proximity to the head of state is therefore no substitute for a sustainable basis of government. The resignation should not, however, be understood as a restoration of normal parliamentary politics. The decision on the formation of the next government remains largely in Hindenburg’s hands; Papen remains a close confidant of the Reich President. It is not until 2 December that Hindenburg finally dismisses the government and appoints Kurt von Schleicher as Chancellor. 17 November therefore marks an important turning point within an ongoing state crisis, not its resolution. Analytically, the episode shows the limits of a model of government that seeks to bypass parliamentary majorities but cannot entirely eliminate parliament’s powers.

17 November 1939: German occupiers close Czech universities

On 17 November 1939, the German occupation authorities in the Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia announce the closure of Czech universities. In the early hours of the morning, German forces shoot nine representatives of student organisations without trial. A notice from Reich Protector Konstantin von Neurath initially provides for a three-year closure; in fact, the universities affected remain closed until the end of the war. The direct connection to Germany lies in the responsibility of the Nazi leadership and its occupation apparatus for this act of violence. It was preceded by protests against the German occupation. The medical student Jan Opletal who was shot during demonstrations on 28 October, dies on 11 November. His funeral on 15 November becomes the starting point for further protests. The Nazi leadership then decides in Berlin to take violent action. Shortly before midnight on 16 November, German police and SS units begin raids on student halls of residence. The events specific to 17 November are the shootings and the announcement of the university closures. The repression is directed not merely against individual demonstrators, but against Czech university life as a whole. The arrests are followed by the deportation of around 1,200 students to Sachsenhausen concentration camp. This deportation is a consequence of the operation and should not be indiscriminately dated to the same day as all the other measures. Taken together, murder, imprisonment and the denial of educational opportunities amount to an attack on society’s capacity for self-determination. The event therefore belongs to German history, even though its principal setting is Prague : it documents the cross-border consequences of German dictatorship and occupation.

17 November 1989: Hans Modrow proposes a treaty community ahead of

On 17 November 1989, Hans Modrow presents his government in the Volkskammer and outlines its programme. The new prime minister of the German Democratic Republic announces reforms to the political system, the economy, education and administration. At the same time, he proposes expanding relations with the Federal Republic of Germany into a treaty community. This means significantly closer cooperation between two states that would remain independent, not their immediate unification. Modrow remains committed to the goal of a renewed socialist society. His government is to be accountable to citizens and guided more strongly by openness, legality and competent administration. The economic crisis is also explicitly among the challenges it intends to address. The statement thus combines promises of reform with an attempt to restore the existing state’s capacity to act. Modrow describes not an entirely fresh start, but a renewal that is intended to preserve the achievements and foundations of the system to date. This distinction is central to the relationship between the two German states. A treaty community is intended to go beyond existing agreements while preserving the German Democratic Republic’s state independence. The proposal should therefore not be read retrospectively as a step towards reunification that had already been decided. Rather, it represents an alternative being pursued at the time: closer cooperation instead of accession to the Federal Republic. This is precisely what gives the government statement its historical significance. It shows that the German question after fall of the Berlin Wall allowed for different political answers, and that Modrow sought to combine a reformed socialist state with a new quality of relations between the two German states.

One date, many stories

These four anniversaries call for different standards: a social policy promise, the failure of a government, a crime committed by an occupying power and a political reform effort must not be equated. Read together, however, they sharpen our understanding of the relationship between state power and society. Precise dating is equally important: an announcement is not yet a law, a resignation is not yet a change of government, and a proposal for cooperation is not yet a decision in favour of political unity.

Editor: Phillipe Schmidt-Araguin (Article created with AI assistance).

Sources