Politics

Transport Ministry rejects plans for car toll

According to a report, an expert study recommends a car toll to fund the motorways. On 21 November 2026, the Transport Ministry said it was not preparing to introduce one.

The Federal Ministry of Transport is not preparing, despite a recommendation from an expert report, to introduce a car toll . A spokesperson told the Tagesspiegel on 21 November 2026 that the coalition agreement contained no such mandate; the ministry was also not currently considering such a charge. The Spiegel had previously reported on a confidential expert report proposing a distance-based charge to fund the motorways.

According to the report, the study examines the planned financial reform of Autobahn GmbH. The state-owned company is to be allowed to take out loans itself in future and receive part of the revenue from the HGV toll . According to the media report, the experts at the public consultancy PD do not believe these funds will be sufficient in the long term to cover both investment needs and borrowing costs.

According to the report, they examined assigning all lorry toll revenue to the company as an alternative, or supplementing its planned share with a distance-based car toll. The second option came out best in the report in terms of long-term financial stability. This is an assessment made within the study, not a government decision. It does not settle the level or specific design of any possible charge.

At the heart of the debate is the question of how to fund motorway maintenance and expansion reliably over several years. Borrowing could bring investment forward; at the same time, interest and repayments would have to be paid later. If toll revenue is earmarked for this, the same funds are no longer available to the same extent for other purposes. Some lorry toll revenue is currently also used for the railways.

A statement published independently of the confidential expert report, for the Transport Committee of the Bundestag, also questions whether the financial reform will resolve the revenue problem permanently. The economist Philippa Sigl-Glöckner wrote on 18 November 2026 that funding shortfalls might simply be pushed into the future. A permanently sustainable funding model would require higher revenues, for example from a car toll or from toll revenues currently allocated to the railways. She also warned of higher financing costs and weaker parliamentary oversight.

An earlier German attempt to introduce a car toll had European Court of Justice failed. On 18 June 2019, the court ruled that the charge at the time, combined with a reduction in motor vehicle tax, breached EU law. In practice, the financial burden would have fallen almost exclusively on owners and drivers of vehicles from other Member States. The ruling concerned that specific combination; it did not declare every car toll unlawful in principle.

Funding for Autobahn GmbH therefore remains the immediate political point of contention in the current reform. The expert report has once again raised the question of an additional charge for motorists, but according to the Transport Ministry, it is not part of the preparations currently under way.

Editor: Phillipe Schmidt-Araguin (Article created with AI assistance).

Sources