Politics

Pistorius rejects US criticism of Ukrainian attacks

On 17 November 2026, Defence Minister Boris Pistorius rejected Washington’s criticism of Ukrainian attacks on targets far behind the front line. Differences of opinion among Ukraine’s supporters emerged at a meeting in Brussels…

Federal Defence Minister Boris Pistorius On 17 November 2026, he strongly rejected American criticism of Ukrainian attacks far behind the front line. It was “pretty stupid” to criticise strikes on strategic military targets and facilities used for military purposes in Russia, he said after a meeting of the Ukraine Contact Group in Brussels. Earlier, a US Department of Defence official had questioned the effectiveness of such attacks.

The German minister pointed to Russian attacks on Ukraine’s civilian energy, water and heating supplies. Instead of criticising Ukrainian attacks on non-civilian targets, people should be discussing Russia’s attacks, Pistorius said. His assessment referred to attacks he described as lawful and legitimate; this does not amount to an independent legal assessment of each individual attack.

The American Under-Secretary of State Elbridge Colby had argued at the meeting that attacks deep inside Russia would not stop the Russian advance at the front. In his view, attacks on civilian infrastructure in particular could even strengthen the resolve of the Russian population and the Kremlin’s willingness to escalate. Ukraine’s supporters should focus more on equipment for fighting at the front.

The remarks came on the day of a Ukrainian attack on the Crimean Bridge. The crossing over the Kerch Strait links mainland Russia to the Ukrainian peninsula of Crimea, which Russia has annexed. Ukraine said it had used drones and missiles in the attack. The bridge is also of strategic importance to Russia as a transport link.

Pistorius co-chaired the Ukraine Contact Group meeting at Nato headquarters with British Defence Minister Wes Streeting. In this forum, countries supporting Ukraine discuss military aid. Colby also attended the meeting. Streeting also disagreed with the American assessment: it was not for partners to tell Ukraine how to conduct its war. In his view, attacks on distant targets had weakened Russia’s war machine and saved lives.

The dispute highlights differing priorities among Ukraine’s supporters. While Washington stressed the immediate impact at the front, the German and British ministers pointed to the military value of attacks away from the front line. Their statements do not, however, mean that the supporters have ended their cooperation or abandoned joint aid programmes.

Satellite communications were another topic. Asked about restrictions on the Starshield system and their impact on defence against Russian drones, Colby declined to go into detail, according to the Associated Press (AP). Streeting stressed that sustained and reliable access to satellite services was important because lives depended on it. The differing assessments of the attacks and the question of what technology is available are therefore two sides of the same debate: Ukraine’s means of defence and how they are used.

Editor: Phillipe Schmidt-Araguin (Article created with AI assistance).

Sources