The Federal Administrative Court has ruled in favour of the former mayor of Todtmoos, Janette Fuchs, in a dispute over her pay. The municipality in Baden-Württemberg must pay her around €36,500 in lost salary and €7,000 in compensation under the judgment of 19 November 2026. At the start of her term, Fuchs was placed in a lower pay grade than her male predecessors and successors.
The court in Leipzig overturned a ruling by the Baden-Württemberg Higher Administrative Court, thereby reinstating the substance of the first-instance judgment by the Freiburg Administrative Court. The central question was whether the difference in grading amounted to discrimination on the grounds of sex.
Fuchs led the Black Forest municipality in Waldshut district from 2014 to 2022. The municipal council initially placed her in pay grade A 14 and only approved the higher grade, A 15, halfway through her term. By contrast, both her predecessor and her successor were paid at grade A 15 from the outset. Fuchs considered this to be discrimination on the grounds of sex and sought back pay and compensation.
Under the relevant state provisions, municipal councils in communities of this size may choose between the two pay grades. They are to take population size and the degree of difficulty of the office into account. The case therefore concerned a municipal decision made within a state-law framework; it was assessed, among other things, under the nationwide General Act on Equal Treatment.
The Federal Administrative Court considered the lower grading to constitute less favourable treatment. Although the lower courts had found no evidence that the municipal council had acted for reasons related to sex, an indication of unlawful discrimination lay in the fact that Fuchs alone was made subject to a probationary condition, and that a review halfway through her term was ordered for her despite there being no provision for this in law.
According to the court, the municipality bore the burden of proof to rebut the resulting presumption of discrimination. It had failed to do so in the proceedings. The decisive factor was therefore not proof of an explicitly discriminatory motive, but the legal assessment of the established circumstances and the counterarguments.
The municipality rejected the allegation of discrimination. Its lawyer told SWR that the requirements of the office had differed at the respective times. The higher grading of the two men had nothing to do with their sex.
The lower courts had reached different conclusions: the Freiburg Administrative Court had ruled largely in Fuchs’s favour in 2025. In 2026, the Higher Administrative Court dismissed her claim following the municipality’s appeal. Among other things, it did not consider her successor a suitable comparator for assessing the decision made in 2014. The Federal Administrative Court has now reinstated the first-instance ruling.
Editor: Mira Cadena (Article created with AI assistance).